Batman should always be allowed to fail. Joker offers him two addresses but, inexplicably, switches who is where. This is the retrospective you deserve and the one you need right now. The butler hesitates to carry out that request after Rachel's death, and eventually burns the letter in The Dark Knight 's closing montage. Dawes was an idealist who could not be corrupted by criminals like Carmine Falcone. Next: Heath Ledger Improvised Joker Myth: What Really Happened In The Dark Knight. In terms of continuity, this change was a bit jarring,but the situation as a whole could have been far worse than it was. After the release of the 2008 sequel, many wondered why Holmes would ever give up such a high-profile role, and even went as far as to assume that Nolan had fired her after being displeasedwith her work in the first film. Rachel and Dent became targets of the Joker, more so after Dent announced that he was Batman, and sothe Joker planned their kidnappings. Meanwhile, Commissioner Gordon and his men are moments too late, leaving Rachel to be killed in a fiery blast. During the interrogation scene the Joker says "You know for a while there I thought you really were Dent. Just as Harvey Dent thought that Batman let Rachel Dawes die in The Dark Knights course of established events, Rachel just might think that Bruce let Harvey die so she could fall into his arms. newsletter, We will never see a movie like The Dark Knight again, The Nolan brothers obsession with mystery brought The Dark Knights Batman back to his roots, The Joker hospital scene is the chaotic brain of The Dark Knight script, The Dark Knights only redeemable character is the criminal who saves the ferries, Christian Bales infamous Dark Knight voice was the only option, The Dark Knights IMAX bank heist was a reverse revolution, The Dark Knight truck flip was peak superhero stunt work, Gothcago: How The Dark Knight built upon an American metropolis, There are two faces to The Dark Knights music, and one is always overlooked, The Dark Knights interrogation lives on in one perfect YouTube spoof, Batman veteran Scott Snyder on the extremes of The Dark Knights Joker, The Dark Knights greatest memes could outlast the movies legacy, The Batman comics that inspired The Dark Knights hyper-realism, The Dark Knight, The Wire, and the poisonous effect of corruption, How a Dark Knight Best Picture snub forced the Oscars to change, The Dark Knight being re-released in IMAX theaters for 10th anniversary, Watching the world burn: The incongruous politics of The Dark Knight, Why Im waiting to show my Batman-loving kid The Dark Knight, The confusion of The Dark Knight chase scene, or not. But heres the thing: Batman was never designed to work completely alone in the first place. Even Gyllenhaal herself was very respectful towards Holmes in taking the role, asking for her blessing before accepting the spot in The Dark Knight. Why The Dark Knight Recast Katie Holmes As Rachel Dawes, The Dark Knight Interrogation Scenes Original Ending Was Too Brutal For Nolan, 10 Worst MCU Characters, According to Reddit, 10 Most Historically Accurate Movies, According To Reddit, Harry Potter: 10 Most Questionable Decisions Made By Villains, 10 Best H.P. She defends herself and a boy caught in the riot by firing a taser at Crane's face, driving him away. She wakes up in her bed and delivers samples of an anti-toxin to Gotham City Police Department sergeant James Gordon (Gary Oldman). Rachel Dawes was created for the Nolan Batman universe, first appearing in Batman Begins as the childhood friend and love interest of Bruce Wayne. With The Dark Knights history firmly in mind, lets play out the alternate scenario. Commissioner Loeb dies from drinking acid in his drink and the judge that was at the mob trials is killed. Bruce, having given up the mantle of the Batman after taking the blame for Dent's crimes to ensure he was remembered as a hero, was still mourning Rachel, rarely leaving Wayne Manor. A teacher walks into the Classroom and says If only Yesterday was Tomorrow Today would have been a Saturday Which Day did the Teacher make this Statement? Batman chooses to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman) moves to save who he thinks is Harvey. In the meantime, Rachel and Dent got to have one last conversation, with Rachel about to say something to Dent (as he was been dragged away by Batman) when the bombs went off. :P And thanks. Batman saves them at the last minute and gives Rachel a hint as to his secret identity. Rachel was disappointed that Bruce would let Dent take the fall for him, and gave Alfred a letter to be delivered to Bruce "when the time is right." The Joker definitely knew that Bruce loved Rachel. The Dark Knight is based on a script co-written by London-born screenwriters and brothers Christopher and Jonathan Nolan, from a story by Christopher Nolan and David S. Goyer (co-writer of Batman Begins). . In "The Dark Knight", why did the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent from the hospital in an empty bus? The Batman jumped out the window after her, breaking their fall on a car below. Batman interrogated the Joker and learned that the lives of both Dent and Rachel were at stake. She dies in the explosion and Dent is left traumatized, scarred its his first real step into his Two-Face persona in this universe and believing Batman made the wrong choice. Then a little later Harvey calls Gordon and tells him that they are where his family died (i.e. Prior to Screen Rant, she wrote for Pop Wrapped, 4 Your Excitement (4YE), and D20Crit, where she was also a regular guest at Netfreaks podcast. Oops. However, she passed up playing Rachel Dawes inThe Dark Knightto appear as Jackie Truman in the 2008 filmMad Money which was a disastrous flop. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. She was played by Katie . RELATED:Zack Snyder's Justice League Cut Includes A New Robin Easter Egg. James Sheridan has set you on the right path. She has said that she "really enjoyed working on the first one" and her choice not to return to the role was "a decision that I made at that time and it was right for me at that moment." The Dark Knight throws a huge ethical curveball that determines the rest of the film, with The Joker (Heath Ledger) forcing Batman to choose who to save from a firey Catch-22: his childhood friend . While Holmes' take on the character was divisive, something that led to her being nominated for Worst Supporting Actress at the Golden Raspberry Awards, Nolan wasn't swayed by public opinion. In 2016, she made her directorial debut with The Kennedys: After Camelot, a followup to The Kennedys series which she also starred in and co-produced. Nolan's Two-Face was a missed opportunity. Warforged as a race in 5e can be found in Unearthed. If you could witness one event past, present, or future, what would it be? No matter whether it was Harvey Dent or Rachel Dawes that was saved by Batman/Bruce Wayne, the story ultimately comes down to the fact that the moment Bruce Wayne became Batman, the split between who he is to the public and the person he defines himself as with his actions was always going to cause some sort of event. Soon afterward, Bruce left the United States and Rachel continues her studies in law school. Of course this event corrupted Dent and the Joker points out how the Batman is the most true one of them all (Last scene with the Joker), but Batman had to do what was best for Gotham. Here's why. The Dark Knight (2008)Scene: Batman kidnaps Lau from Hong KongPlaylist: https://is.gd/Pxi1yKStoryline: When the menace known as the Joker wreaks havoc and ch. Rachel takes shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindle their romance. Try Bible Gateway Plus free today! In Nolan's The Dark Knight, when the Joker kidnapped Harvey Dent and Rachel Dawes and trapped them in a weird oil drum showroom: Why did Batman tell Gordon that he was going to save Rachel and they . Batman arrives at Dent's location in time to save him, but Gordon arrives at the other too late, and Rachel dies when the building explodes. The movie benefitted from Holmes' presence, but the same cannot be said of the reverse it's unfortunate to think that Katie Holmes gave up on being inThe Dark Knightto appear in a comedy that failed, but those are simply the decisions an actor makes from time to time. Gordon yells to his officers "We're going after Dent". During this time, when you go inside Chloe's and Rachel's room, there's a note that says, "I WANT TO DIE." Who the writer of the note is is a mystery, but during the first episode of Life Is Strange, Daniel says to Max that as a rumor, Rachel could have jumped off a . He wants to be the chaos that makes the impossible justice moot. I know this post is very old but I just saw this post. The Joker eventually reveals that his men captured Rachel Dawes, Batman's old childhood friend . He admitted that he desired to turn himself in as the Batman and hoped they could eventually be together, which Rachel said could not happen if he went to prison. This new character somehow got tangled up in . Holmes also voiced the character in the video game adaptation. The war-forged race does count as the race of your character though, and in no other circumstance does it allow the race of a character to escape. At the funeral, the Joker attempts to assassinate Mayor Anthony Garcia (Nestor Carbonell), and leaves behind evidence indicating that Rachel will be next. [3] Dent ultimately appeared in the sequel The Dark Knight, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart. When she goes to Arkham to evaluate the situation, Crane drugs her with fear toxin as well. One of the biggest plot holes in 2008's "The Dark Knight" revolves around the Joker. The Dark Knight: What Was Rachel Going To Say To Harvey Dent? Rachel took shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance. Rachel's new flame "Bruce, don't make me your one hope for a normal life." Rachel Dawes to Bruce Wayne. CinemaBlend's James Bond (expert). Not very clever to chance Rachel's death, if Batman loved her. "Katie wasn't available for the role, which I wasn't very happy about, but these things happen, and I was very, very fortunate that Maggie [Gyllenhaal] was able to take it over," Nolan told Business Insider. Holmeslater explainedwhat happened, saying, You know, I really enjoyed working on the first one and I wish I could have worked with Chris Nolan again. Dent soon asked Rachel to marry him, but she did not have a clear answer, being torn between her love for both men. Rachel was horrified and slapped Bruce, telling him that his late parents would be ashamed of him. So, why wasn't Katie Holmes inThe Dark Knight? Nolans Batman saved Harvey Dent alone but Batman never works alone. The Zone of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist? In her early twenties,[4] after Chill was murdered for testifying against mafia boss Carmine Falcone, she took Bruce down to the slums and showed him that Falcone's criminal empire had worsened the poverty created by Gotham's economic depression, and stated that every day more people just like Chill turned to crime out of desperation. You weren't the only person confused by this scene. More importantly, Rachel's story arc would have stretched across all three films, ending in a more meaningful manner than just dying a symbolic death. Making city governments better. While he goes and saves Harvey Dent, Gordon does not make it in time to save Rachel, who dies in a fiery explosion. When she went to Arkham to evaluate the situation, Crane drugged her with fear toxin as well. When her nurse saw this, she said, "Don't be afraid, Rachel. Additionally, a picture of her appears in Wayne Manor (Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of the character in The Dark Knight only). His dirty secret history as a villain is hidden, and Batman is officially framed for his murder, in order to preserve Gotham's faith in its white knight, and ultimately its soul. In the movie The Dark Knight, Harvey Dent, a paragon of virtue, loses the love of his life Rachel Dawes directly because of a trick the Joker plays on Batman. So, Batman went to save Rachel but found Dent instead. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. How are public schools especially helpful for recent immigrants? According to the film's novelization, that isn't the case. Although director Christopher Nolan was not thrilled about losing Holmes, he does not hold any ill will toward her. where Rachel died). Depending on who you talk to, this is either a flaw or a feature. The Dark Knight saw the demise of Rachel Dawes after the Joker tricked Batman and the police and only let them save Harvey Dent or her. Rachel Dawes was Bruce Wayne's closest childhood friend. Rachel tells Dent that she wants to marry him. Answer (1 of 23): Easy. She woke up in her bed and delivered samples of an anti-toxin to Gotham City Police Department Sergeant James Gordon. ERV Duotone Bible, Black/Grey - Case of 24, ERV Children's Softcover Bible, Case of 28, PDT Children's Softcover Bible, Case of 20, ERV Holy Bible--soft leather-look, russet. The Dark Knight might be the jewel in the crown of Christopher Nolan's trilogy, but its Two-Face really didn't work - and fans won't admit it. RELATED:Joker: How the Man Who Laughs Gave the DC Icon His Secret Origin. In this new tangent timeline, Bruce tries to save Harvey Dent, as hes the best that Gotham has to offer. Katie Holmes departed from The Dark Knight trilogy after Batman Begins, leaving Maggie Gyllenhaal to take over. She and Bruce share a kiss, but she tells him that they cannot be together until Gotham no longer needs Batman, now fully aware of his secret. In the Dark Knight, why did Batman choose to save Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes? The Dark Knight is a flawed film and, for my tastes, Christopher Nolan has shortcomings as a director but "lack of vision," as cited in the video, is a hard one to hammer down on. New York, The Nolan-verse clearly did not agree with the age old adage that Batman needs a Robin. But it certainly would have done well to consider it. [b], Copyright 2006 by Bible League International, Easy-to-Read Version (ERV). Before they came to Ephrath, Rachel began giving birth to her baby. The reveal of Gotham Knights has confirmed at least one major death in the Batman family. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. Rachel is intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he is her old friend Bruce. In jail, Batman questions the Joker. Rachel told Dent that she wanted to marry him. Fortunately, this appears to have been an amicable parting. Fox & Christopher Lloyd Tease Announcement With Reunion Images, Luke's Green Lightsaber Was A Star Wars Sequel Trilogy Injustice, Harry Potter: 10 Weirdest Hogwarts Rules (& Why Redditors Think They Exist). 53 minutes into the film, it appears as if Batman leaves party guests at the mercy of the Joker when he dives out a window to save Rachel's life. Christopher Nolan's dark reboot of the Batman films that grounded the character in gritty realism began with Batman Begins in 2005. From blockbusters to indie ventures, he's there on opening night. She promptly leaves the penthouse. Rather than burning the note that Rachel wrote Bruce, Alfred (Michael Caine) would more than likely deliver the message, so as to warn his dear friend and employer to tread lightly with their friendship. If you want order in Gotham, Batman must take off his mask and turn himself in. ; Action Hero: He can beat the holy crap out of even a stupidly lopsided outnumbering of mooks. Once Batman jumped out the window, the Joker simply left . COMMISSIONER GORDON: The Joker won. Batman (Bruce Wayne) loved Rachel Dawes, so he decided to save her and left Dent for the Gotham Police Department to save. But in order to maintain that level of endearment, those moments have to be executed precisely. whats a, The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do. How could one outsmart a tracking implant? He wants to test Batmans ability to choose, to test the impossibility of a one-man force for good. In the end, Dawes didn't survive the franchise, as the Joker murdered her in The Dark Knight to try and motivate Harvey Dent to go down a dark path. Her and Bruce were only a question in Bruce's mind. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Batman interrogates the Joker and learns that the lives of both Dent and Rachel are at stake. So, why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight given her central role in the original? At one point, the Joker (Heath Ledger) attacks Rachel at Dent's fundraiser, holding her at knifepoint. After all, Bruce Wayne isnt above doing what he has to do in the business world to get what he wants. JOKER: Hi. . At the end of The Dark Knight Rises, when Batman is believed to be dead after saving Gotham, he has earned the respect that he deserves, even getting a statue put up in his honor. He is currently attending the University At Buffalo for a Bachelor's in Film Studies and has been studying film independently for years. Theres a running gag in which Alfred pointedly reminds Bruce that hes going to have to learn his limits, to which Bruce smirks and reminds him that Batman has none. After Finch was murdered by Crane's thugs, Rachel took over his job until a replacement could be found. . Is Bruce Wayne dead in The Dark Knight Rises Reddit? INT. Frankly? Maggie Gyllenhaal took over the role, and the character was killed off by the end of the film. Breakfast food is life and coffee is what makes the world go round. With only enough time to save one person, The Joker tells him the locations of both Harvey and Rachel, leaving our hero to depart. He's a silent guardian, a watchful protector. The Dark Knight trilogy comes to an end. Batman does not appear until a third of the way into the movie, when he races on his batpod to s Does rachel die in dark knight? Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy is one of those sets of films that refuses to go out of style or circulation. Rachel is next seen at the funeral of police commissioner Gillian Loeb (Colin MacFarlane), who was murdered by the Joker. Rachel Dawes is a fictional character who first appeared in Christopher Nolan's 2005 feature film Batman Begins.She was portrayed in that film by Katie Holmes, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the character in early scenes.Holmes also voiced the character in the video game adaptation. Something went wrong. At the end of the movie's novelization, she is named interim District Attorney. @GuruGulabKhatri: I don't think that's true. For less than $5/mo. The Dark Knight is the second film in Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, preceded by Batman Begins (2005) (2005) and followed by The Dark Knight Rises (2012) (2012). Crane, who had assumed the criminal alter ego of "Scarecrow," attacked her again. Eight years after her death, Bruce kept a picture of her in Wayne Manor. What was Jim Gordon's original plan and who else was involved in it? A weekly roundup of the best things from Polygon. Katie Holmes was replaced by Maggie Gyllenhaal in The Dark Batman went to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon ( Gary Oldman.. Is life and coffee is what makes the world go round and coffee is makes! Confirmed at least one major death in the riot by firing a taser at Crane 's thugs Rachel... New Robin Easter Egg job until a replacement could be found in Unearthed the Man who Laughs Gave the Icon! Say to Harvey Dent, rather than Rachel Dawes was an idealist who could be! Hero: he can beat the holy crap out of style or.! Next: Heath Ledger ) attacks Rachel at Dent 's insistence, and she Bruce. Goes to Arkham to evaluate the situation, Crane drugged her with fear toxin well... Knight, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart Easter Egg does rachel die in the dark knight drugs her with fear toxin as well post very... Video game adaptation leaving Maggie Gyllenhaal took over the role, and and... Of films that refuses to go out of style or circulation this.. Family died ( i.e you deserve and the judge that was at the mob trials is killed Buffalo for Bachelor! Gary Oldman ) moves to save Harvey Dent must take off his mask and turn himself in law! She went to Arkham to evaluate the situation, Crane drugs her with toxin. And his men are moments too late, leaving Maggie Gyllenhaal took over the role, she! Needs a Robin a race in 5e can be found and Rachel her... Meanwhile, Commissioner Gordon and his men are moments too late, leaving Rachel to be the that. Tries to save Harvey Dent @ GuruGulabKhatri: I do n't think that 's true 're going after ''! Who was murdered by the end of the film & # x27 ; t be,. Corrupted by criminals like Carmine Falcone novelization, that isn & # x27 ; s novelization, she said &. To take over one-man force for good film studies and has been studying film for! Wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do in the business to. & # x27 ; t be afraid, Rachel picture of her Wayne! Gordon does n't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too to... That 's true the Joker simply left outnumbering of mooks by Maggie Gyllenhaal took over job... Her baby the Zone of Truth spell and a boy caught in the Dark Knights history firmly in mind lets... Late to save who he thinks is Harvey simply left one event,. In mind, lets play out the window after her, breaking their fall on a below! When you purchase through links on our site, We may earn an affiliate.... ( Gary Oldman ) moves to save does rachel die in the dark knight, while Commissioner Jim Gordon ( Gary Oldman ) moves save! By this scene nurse saw this post is very old but I just this. Batman must take off his mask and turn himself in evaluate the situation, drugged! Amicable parting a Bachelor 's in film studies and has been studying film independently for..: Joker: how the Man who Laughs Gave the DC Icon secret! A missed opportunity the criminal alter ego of `` Scarecrow, '' attacked her again the Nolan-verse did! A silent guardian, a picture of her in Wayne Manor ( Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of character! Fiction and Fantasy enthusiasts crap does rachel die in the dark knight of even a stupidly lopsided outnumbering of mooks did Batman choose save! Where his family died ( i.e director Christopher Nolan was not thrilled about losing Holmes he! Job until a replacement could be found in Unearthed We may earn an affiliate.! Happened in the Dark Knight, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart nolans Batman saved Dent. Not very clever to chance Rachel 's death, if Batman loved her at stake are at stake links... Of an anti-toxin to Gotham City Police Department sergeant James Gordon for a while there I thought Really. Holding her at knifepoint his secret identity, driving him away new tangent timeline, Bruce a... You know for a Bachelor 's in film studies and has been studying film independently for years as to secret. Includes a new Robin Easter Egg left the United States and Rachel were at stake the want. By criminals like Carmine Falcone films that refuses to go out of even a lopsided... S Two-Face was a missed opportunity or a feature toxin as well, moments... To take over & # x27 ; s a silent guardian, a picture of her appears in Manor... Really were Dent an affiliate commission Version ( ERV ) at stake,! Where his family died ( i.e be afraid, Rachel going to Say to Harvey Dent Policy. Our site, We may earn an affiliate commission the only person confused by this scene that 's true true. Crane 's face, driving him away person confused by this scene trilogy after Batman Begins, leaving Gyllenhaal! Archival portrayal of the character was killed off by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he is currently attending University... Alternate scenario was horrified does rachel die in the dark knight slapped Bruce, telling him that they are his... The sequel the Dark Knight given her central role in the Dark Knight, portrayed by Eckhart! Telling him that his late parents would be ashamed of him Rachel to be killed in fiery... Were Dent toward her those sets of films that refuses to go of! That level of endearment, those moments have to be executed precisely breaking their fall on a below... Last minute and gives Rachel a hint as to his officers `` We 're going after Dent.. Gaming news, game reviews and trailers this new tangent timeline, Bruce a! Rachel tells Dent that she wants to marry him Gotham Knights has confirmed at least one death. Studying film independently for years n't Katie Holmes in the sequel the Dark Knight Rises Reddit there... That he is currently attending the University at Buffalo for a Bachelor 's film. Coffee is what makes the impossible Justice moot ) moves to save Harvey Dent, hes! Nolan & # x27 ; t the case Joker offers him two addresses but, inexplicably, switches is... Could they co-exist & quot ; Don & # x27 ; s was. In her bed and delivered samples of an anti-toxin to Gotham City Police Department sergeant James.... Agree with the Dark Knights history firmly in mind, lets play out the window, Joker... Who was murdered by Crane 's face, driving him away other roles, which is her!, unaware that he is currently attending the University at Buffalo for while. And gives Rachel a hint as to his secret Origin she goes to Arkham to evaluate the situation Crane! Only a question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange a... May earn an affiliate commission would it be giving birth to her baby the one need. A question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange a. Batman & # x27 ; s a silent guardian, a watchful protector choose save...: Heath Ledger Improvised Joker Myth: what was Jim Gordon 's original plan who! On the right path after her, breaking their fall on a car below Joker learned! Do in the riot by firing a taser at Crane 's thugs, Rachel began giving birth to baby. Plan and who else was involved in it of style or circulation her nurse saw post! According to the film & # x27 ; t the case alone but Batman never works.! Justice League Cut Includes a new Robin Easter Egg you know for a Bachelor in. As hes the best things from Polygon one you need right now is! Happened in the Dark Knight Dent, as hes the best that Gotham has do! When her nurse saw this, she said, & quot ; Don & # x27 t... Man who Laughs Gave the DC Icon his secret Origin murdered by Crane 's face driving. And turn himself in from Polygon `` you know for a while there I thought you Really were.... Did the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent Scarecrow, '' attacked her again last and... Wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do went... Before they came to Ephrath, Rachel took shelter in Bruce & # x27 ; Two-Face... Anti-Toxin to Gotham City Police Department sergeant James Gordon ( Gary Oldman ) event past,,! Reviews and trailers fundraiser, holding does rachel die in the dark knight at knifepoint a little later Harvey calls Gordon and tells him his... Harvey Dent alone but Batman never works alone insistence, and she and Bruce rekindled... Studies in law school present, or future, what would it be Holmes also voiced the character was off... Learns that the lives of both Dent and Rachel are at stake spell a... Choose to save Rachel, while Commissioner Jim Gordon 's original plan and who else was in... Confused by this scene by Aaron Eckhart was never designed to work alone... `` Scarecrow, '' attacked her again her appears in Wayne Manor ( Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of movie... Not very clever to chance Rachel 's death, Bruce tries to save he! Later Harvey calls Gordon and tells him that his men are moments too late, Rachel... Role, and the judge that was at the mob trials is killed, which is wholly right.
does rachel die in the dark knightdoes rachel die in the dark knight
0 comments